“And get another box of Jelly Slugs, dear, they’ve nearly cleaned us out–” said a woman’s voice.
-Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, J.K. Rowling
There’s little known about Jelly Slugs, other than that they’re sold at Honeydukes and seem to be quite popular. So I let imagination take over with this one. I knew I didn’t want a regular jello flavour of lemon or mango or lime. As I was researching slugs, I found out that there are banana slugs found in North America. From there I thought of banoffee pie, made of bananas, cream and toffee, an English dessert, created in 1971 in East Sussex.
Fortunately, in the supermarket, they sell a jar of banoffee dessert sauce, so I decided to give it a go.
Print
Jelly Slugs | Harry Potter
- Yield: 14-16 slugs 1x
Description
Make these jelly slugs from Honeydukes, a popular treat in their Hogmeade shop. We’ve made ours banoffee flavoured!
Ingredients
- 1 box of ‘make your own/flavourless’ jello
- 7–8 tbsp powdered gelatine
- 1/4 cup water
- 300g jar of banoffee dessert sauce
Instructions
- In a saucepan, over low-medium heat, stir together the jello, powdered gelatine and water.
- Stir until all is dissolved and the mixture has lost it’s grittiness.
- Add in the banoffee sauce.
- Stirring, let it heat up, but don’t let it boil or bubble, just until the sauce is smooth and flows off the spoon when lifted.
- Using a smaller spoon, scoop into the slug mold.
- Place the old into the freezer for 5-10 minutes, depending on how warm the mixture is, until it is firm and pops out of the mold easily.
- Repeat. If the mixture starts to firm up in the pot, just reheat slightly until it’s smooth again.
Notes
The slug mold was created using these two products, purchased via Amazon (affiliate links).
Banana Slugs
Easy Mold Silicone Molding Putty
Make more molds if you’re in a rush.
Looking for the packaging I’ve created? You can download it for free by clicking the image below, but only use it for private use.
Harry Potter Honeydukes Jelly Slugs Packaging (973 downloads)
If I want to make mine a “normal” flavor what could I use instead of the sauce? Anything helps, thanks!
Any jello flavour or thick sweet dessert sauce should do the trick.
Hi, are these the same texture as jelly or more stiff? Also do they need to be stored in the fridge? How many days could have make these in advance?
Hi Lara, they’re stiffer, more like soft gummy candies. All the ingredients are from the shelf products, but I figure storing in the fridge might make them last longer. They’d be fine several days in advance (say 3 to be safe?)
Eeeek, love these, Bryt…now all you need is slime to go with them!
I knew I forgot something! 😉 That would be cool!
I can’t find slug molds anywhere! Can anybody help?
Where did you get the moulds from? I searched everywhere, but couldn’t find anything that looks even remotely like a slug 🙁
Hi Dominique, I made the moulds using a slug toy and Easy Mold Silicone Molding Putty. I swear by this putty (which is food grade). It’s really easy to use, meaning we can make any mould we want 🙂
What’s the difference between the flavorless jello and plain gelatin? I’ve only seen plain gelatin in the US. Can I just use that?
Thanks!
Yes. Knox unflavored gelatin works well.
I’ve looked everywhere, even on the internet, for flavorless jello and it may as well not exist. How much gelatin do I have to use to make this recipe work? I really really want to make this and give it as a christmas gift to my friends, and I have everything I need except the amount of gelatin.
Also, what kind of gelatin do you recommend?
The actual slugs that you buy at universal are actually banana flavoured!!
Hi
Such a great idea, I love it!
I made molds of the same toy slugs. As I couldn’t find banoffee dessert sauce in my country, I tried cooked condensed milk (which is sort of toffee) with banana flavour. Worked quite well.
Now I wanted to take some photographs of the result, using your packaging. But the download doesn’t work 🙁
I’m going to try condensed coconut milk (as my son has dairy allergy.) when you used condensed milk did you cook it down first? Did you substitute equal volume as the banoffe?
I love these and want to make them for my sons Harry Potter birthday. He’s allergic to milk and nuts so we are trying to make safe slugs (and chocolate frogs). Is there something we could substitute the banaffee for that’s nondairy? I could do all jello but I love the texture of yours..trying to think what I could sub…
For the banana slug, you could add condensed down coconut milk or cream, as you mentioned in the other comment, and use a banana food flavour and a toffee food flavour (making sure it’s dairy free). But there are different types of slugs in the world, so don’t feel you have to make banoffee. There are red slugs, so a raspberry dessert sauce could be another option.
Does the slug toy still exist on amazon? I could only find ones that were sticky and soft/stretchy