Last Updated on January 27, 2021

I am in the basement doing shots of water, taking my three-minute break between crunches on the Stomach Master 6000 and leg lifts on the weight bench, when I smell the unmistakable buttery flavor of my mother’s crabby snacks and I start to salivate unmercifully. Because I love crabby snacks, I leave the basement, enter the kitchen, and see that my mother is not only baking crabby snacks, which are buttered crabmeat and orange cheese on English muffins, but she is also making her homemade three-meats pizza – hamburger, sausage, and chicken – and those buffalo wings she gets from Big Foods.

-The Silver Linings Playbook, Matthew Quick

To make crabby snacks is to take a nostalgic trip back to the 1960s and 70s, when cocktail parties included jell-o salads, cheese balls, and pigs in a blanket. While the salads have declined in popularity, crabby snacks continue to be a retro staple on the menu for tailgate parties, football watch parties and Super Bowl celebrations, alongside buffalo wings.

Crabby snacks are just one name for these cheese and crab mixtures, that are baked or broiled on English muffin halves. They also are known as crab bites, crab melts, crab delights, crab toasties, crab melt-a-ways, crabbys or crabbies. If you want to get fancy, you’ll find them under titles of Old English Cheese and Crab Canapés or Hor D’oeuvres.

Good Housekeeping’s Perfect Parties book from 1967 gives some indication on where this recipe derives from. Labeled under “Crab-meat Rabbit” indicates it’s a take on Welsh Rabbit or Rarebit, a toasted bread with a savoury cheese sauce broiled on top, the original ‘recipe’ dating at least back to the 1700s. As with many recipes, as they’re transported across continents, and embedded into cultures, variations make these dishes a country’s own.

Matthew Quick, the author of The Silver Linings Playbook, in an interview mentions the recipe came from his mom’s friend some 30+ years ago off the back of a Kraft Old English Cheese jar. In the 1960s, prepping for the American hostess was all about convenience. Make your dishes tasty, but make them quick and easy for you to toss together. The recipe from Good Housekeeping calls for butter, milk and sharp Cheddar cheese, blended with mustard, cayenne pepper and Worcestershire for flavour on the stove, before folding in the crab meat. Like many brands, Kraft would have seen an opportunity to promote their product as a solution to cut down on prep time.

As many families will have adapted these bite-sized snacks to be their own over the years, there will be non-negotiables in the ingredients. Some may say it’s not crabby snacks without the Old Bay Seasoning, others clearly state Old English Cheese Spread must be used, others will swear by both. I’ve included a few options below so you can make your own choice.

The Silver Linings Playbook; Crabby Snacks

Author: Bryton Taylor
Total Time: 30 minutes

Print Recipe

Description

To make crabby snacks from The Silver Linings Playbook is to take a nostalgic trip back to the 1960s and 70s. Today, crabby snacks continue to be a retro staple on the menu for tailgate parties, football watch parties and Super Bowl celebrations, alongside buffalo wings.

Ingredients

Units Scale

3 tbsp butter
1/4 cup plain flour
1 can crab meat, drained
English muffins

Cheese sauce
1.5 cups milk
1/2 tsp mustard (prepared not powder)
1/4 tsp salt
1 cup sharp Cheddar cheese, grated
OR
one jar Kraft Old English Cheese Spread

Seasonings
dash of cayenne pepper
1/2 tsp Worcestershire
OR
3/4 tsp Old Bay Spice

Instructions

If making from scratch

In a small saucepan, over low heat, melt the butter.
Whisk in the flour, salt, mustard, cayenne, and Worcestershire, before adding in the milk.
Cook while continuing to stir until the sauce is thick and smooth.
Add in the crab meat, stir until the meat is mixed in and warmed up.
Separate the English muffins and place on a baking tray, before spooning the crab sauce mixture on top.
Place under the broiler in your oven for ~5-10 minutes until the sauce is bubbly crisp.

If making using Kraft cheese spread

In a small saucepan, over low heat, melt the butter, before stirring in the crab meat for several minutes until warmed.
Sprinkle in the Old Bay Seasoning, then stir in the jar of Old English Cheese Spread.
Scoop the crab cheese mixture onto the English muffins on a baking tray, and place under the broiler until golden and bubbly.

Cook Time: 10 minutes

References:

Good Housekeeping’s Perfect Parties, Consolidated Book Publishers, Chicago, 1967
Definition of WELSH RABBIT. (2020). Retrieved 1 September 2020, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Welsh%20rabbit
Fannie Merritt Farmer, The Original Boston Cooking-School Cookbook [Facsimile]. Welsh Rarebit II. page 469, 1896

The Silver Linings Playbook; Crabby Snacks